Business Model Generation: Revenue streams

Rent Instead of Buy

Customers pay for the temporary right to use

Illustration of Rent Instead of Buy
Run a Rent Instead of Buy play
Key Partners Key Activities Value Propositions Customer Relationships Customer Segments
Key Resources Channels
Cost Structures Revenue Streams
The business model canvas was designed by Business Model Fondry AG and distributed under a Creative Commons license.

How: Offer your products or services on a rental basis rather than at a fixed price.

Why: Customers benefit from reduced initial acquisition costs and increased financial flexibility when opting to rent rather than buy products, particularly capital-intensive assets.

This business strategy is part of the Business Model Patterns printed card deck.

Proven business models that have driven success for global leaders across industries. Rethink how your business can create, deliver, and capture value.

Get your deck!

Rent for use, not possession

The term Rent Instead of Buy refers to the practice of offering products and services on a rental basis, rather than selling them outright. This option allows customers to access goods that they might not be able to afford to purchase upfront, while also avoiding the need to commit capital for an extended period of time. This can be especially appealing for capital-intensive assets, as it frees up financial resources for other purposes.

One key requirement for offering a rental option is the ability to finance the product in advance, as revenues from providing acecss, or renting out, will only be received at a later date. This is similar to the “Pay Per Use” model, but with the distinction that rentals are typically charged based on the duration of use, rather than the actual usage. It is not uncommon for there to be a degree of overlap between these two models - for example, rental car agencies may charge an additional fee for customers who exceed a predetermined mileage limit.

The circular economy

The Rent Instead of Buy model is closely linked to the circular economy, which represents an alternative to the traditional linear “buy, use, throw away” model. This shift in perspective highlights that the intrinsic value of an asset is not solely determined by the equipment itself, but rather by the use that is made of it and the performance gain that is obtained. This is what is referred to as the economy of use.

Example: renting IT equipment

One of the most common applications of the “rent instead of buy” model can be seen in the realm of IT equipment, such as servers, computers, and printers. Renting these assets, as opposed to buying them outright, can yield a number of benefits. For one, it allows for a high-performance and homogeneous IT system, as the flexibility of an evolutive rental contract enables the replacement of outdated equipment with the latest technology at any point during the term of the contract.

Additionally, renting IT equipment can also result in significant cost savings, as it eliminates the need to bear the maintenance costs associated with outdated equipment. The flexibility of rental agreements also allows businesses to scale their IT infrastructure up or down as needed, providing an added level of cost-efficiency and adaptability.

Why is the Rent Instead of Buy business model interesting for businesses and customers?

There are a number of reasons why the Rent Instead of Buy business model can make sense for the customer.

  • Avoiding Initial Acquisition Costs. One of the biggest advantages of the Rent instead of Buy business model is that it allows customers to avoid the initial acquisition costs associated with buying a product outright. This can make it more accessible for customers who might not have the financial means to purchase a product upfront.
  • Preservation of Financial Leeway. The Rent instead of Buy model also allows customers to preserve their financial leeway, as capital is not locked up for prolonged periods of time. This can be particularly attractive for customers looking to acquire capital-intensive assets.

For businesses, it caan make sense to offer renting over buying to customers for anumber of reasons.

  • Greater Sales Potential. The ability to offer a Rent instead of Buy option can also open up new sales potential for businesses. This is due to the fact that financing the products in question in advance is a prerequisite for such arrangements, as revenues will only come in at a later date.
  • Increased Revenue. Implementing the Rent instead of Buy business model can increase revenue for businesses as it allows them to collect rent payments over a period of time, rather than receiving payment for a product upfront. This can provide a consistent stream of income for the business.

What challenges will companies face s they implement the Rent Instead of Buy business model?

  • Uncertainty of Long-term Profitability. One of the biggest challenges of implementing the Rent instead of Buy business model is the uncertainty of its long-term profitability. This is still being debated in the business world, and retailers must weigh the potential benefits against the risks before investing in this model.
  • Acquiring new customers can also be a challenge when implementing the Rent instead of Buy model, as customers may not be familiar with the concept and may not be inclined to try it out, especially if they are used to buying products outright.
  • Maintenance and Upkeep. Another challenge of implementing the Rent instead of Buy model is the need to maintain and upkeep the equipment being rented out. This can be costly and time-consuming, especially if the equipment is in high demand or if it becomes outdated.
  • Risk of Default. Businesses that implement the Rent instead of Buy model also run the risk of customers defaulting on their rental payments. This can be financially detrimental for the business and can also damage the business’s reputation.

Where did the Rent Instead of Buy business model pattern originate from?

The practice of Rent Instead of Buy, dates back to ancient civilizations, with evidence suggesting that even the Romans engaged in such business transactions as early as 450 BC. This model was later adopted and applied to various sectors, including the medieval noble class, who rented out their lands to farmers in exchange for a tithe of the crops. In modern times, the most prevalent form of renting can be found in the real estate market, with a significant portion of apartments in German-speaking countries being rented rather than owned.

Applying the Rent Instead of Buy business model

The concept of offering products or services on a rental basis, rather than for a fixed price, is a widely applicable strategy. As consumer preferences shift towards a desire to use and access goods rather than necessarily owning them, industries ranging from consumer goods to automotive are starting to adopt this trend. It is likely that other sectors will follow suit in the near future.

Examples

Dropbox

Customers rent hosting space from Dropbox, eliminating the need for physical hard drives shared over internal networks, which was the standard way of sharing files before Dropbox arrived.

Xerox

In the late 1950s, Xerox pioneered the supply of photocopiers on a rental basis to overcome high initial equipment expenditures.

Blockbuster

Blockbuster, a rental service for videos, DVDs, and online films, reached its peak in the late 20th and early 21st centuries with 60,000 employees in 17 countries worldwide. However, mismanagement and increased competition led to significant revenue loss and bankruptcy in 2010.

Airbnb

Airbnb is an online marketplace that allows people to rent out their homes or apartments to travelers. Instead of staying in a hotel, travelers can stay in someone’s home and get a more authentic experience of the local culture. This model has disrupted the traditional hotel industry and it has allowed people to make money by renting out their homes when they’re not using them.

Rent the Runway

Rent the Runway is an online service that allows people to rent designer dresses and accessories for special occasions. Instead of buying a dress or outfit that they’ll only wear once, customers can rent it for a fraction of the cost. This model is particularly popular with women who want to wear a designer dress to a special event but don’t want to spend a lot of money on it.

WeWork

WeWork is a co-working space provider that allows people to rent office space on a flexible basis. Instead of buying or leasing an office, customers can rent a desk or private office on an as-needed basis. This model is particularly popular with freelancers and small business owners who don’t need a full-time office, but still want a professional place to work.

Diebold ATMs

Facing a stagnant market for full-function ATMs, Diebold recognized a growing need for simple cash dispensers in high-traffic areas such as convenience stores and hotel lobbies. Initially, they tried to sell a straightforward cash dispensing product, but the businesses were not interested in buying hardware. Instead, Diebold adapted their approach and offered the cash dispensers as a service, leasing them at affordable rates and earning transaction revenues through convenience fees. This strategy led to the proliferation of mini-ATMs in various locations, turning the product into a service and creating a profitable new business model based on recurring revenues.

Source: The Pinocchio Problem: Why Your Product Wishes It Could Be a Service

Trigger Questions

  • Is it the desire of our customers to possess our products, or are they content with simply utilizing them on a temporary basis?
  • What financing options would be most sustainable in terms of generating a consistent flow of cash for our products?"
  • Are our customers struggling to afford to buy our products outright?
  • Is being more environmentally friendly important for our business?
  • Are we looking for ways to reduce our inventory costs?

This business strategy is part of the Business Model Patterns printed card deck.

Proven business models that have driven success for global leaders across industries. Rethink how your business can create, deliver, and capture value.

Get your deck!
Sources

Want to learn more?

Receive a hand picked list of the best reads on building products that matter every week. Curated by Anders Toxboe. Published every Tuesday.

No spam! Unsubscribe with a single click at any time.

Ice Breakers

Relieve initial group awkwardness and establish a safe space

Educate

Broaden knowledge or insight regarding the behavior or situation to inform decisions.

Demonstrate

Show practical examples or models of the desired behavior for clear guidance.

Alert

Highlight current actions and their reasons, bringing unconscious habits to awareness.

Train

Develop necessary skills and competencies to enable effective action.

Community events
Product Loop

Product Loop provides an opportunity for Product professionals and their peers to exchange ideas and experiences about Product Design, Development and Management, Business Modelling, Metrics, User Experience and all the other things that get us excited.

Join our community

Made with in Copenhagen, Denmark

Want to learn more about about good product development, then browse our product playbooks.